Current:Home > NewsDisputed verdict draws both sides back to court in New Hampshire youth detention center abuse case -Global Wealth Bridge
Disputed verdict draws both sides back to court in New Hampshire youth detention center abuse case
View
Date:2025-04-27 15:08:30
Brentwood, N.H. (AP) — Both sides in a landmark trial over abuse at New Hampshire’s youth detention center returned to the courtroom Monday, seven weeks after jurors delivered what remains an unsettled verdict.
A jury awarded $38 million to David Meehan in May but found the state liable for only one “incident” of abuse at the Youth Development Center in Manchester. Jurors weren’t told that state law caps claims against the state at $475,000 per “incident,” and some later said they wrote “one” on the verdict form to reflect a single case of post-traumatic stress disorder resulting from more than 100 episodes of physical, sexual and emotional abuse.
Meehan’s lawyers have asked Judge Andrew Schulman to set aside just the portion of the verdict where jurors wrote one incident, allowing the $38 million to stand, or to order a new trial focused only on determining the number of incidents. The state, meanwhile, has asked him to impose the cap. Schulman has yet to rule on those motions, and at a hearing Monday, attorneys said more paperwork is coming.
In a May 24 order, Schulman said imposing the cap would be an “unconscionable miscarriage of justice.” He didn’t go that far Monday, but said there was a disconnect between the award and the finding of one incident.
“We don’t know exactly what the jury was thinking,” he said. “But $38 million doesn’t square with a single incident.”
Although they didn’t argue as such at trial, lawyers for the state said jurors appeared to have defined incident as “a single harmful condition” to which the plaintiff was exposed, and as such, the verdict should stand. David Vicinanzo, one of Meehan’s attorneys, characterized that position as “The state is essentially saying, yeah, 100 rapes, 200 rapes, it all equals one rape.”
“What reasonable person thinks that?” he said.
Meehan, 42, went to police in 2017 to report the abuse and sued the state three years later. Since then, 11 former state workers have been arrested although charges against one of them were dropped after the man, now in his early 80s, was found incompetent to stand trial.
Over the four-week trial, Meehan’s attorneys argued that the state encouraged a culture of abuse marked by pervasive brutality, corruption and a code of silence. The state, which portrayed Meehan as a violent child, troublemaking teenager and delusional adult, argued that he waited too long to sue and that it shouldn’t be held liable for the actions of “rogue” employees.
Schulman already rejected what he called the two worst options: reconvening the jury or questioning them about their decision. Other options would be ordering a new trial or adjusting the number of incidents on the verdict form. That latter would be something akin to a process by which a judge can add damages to an original amount awarded by the jury if a defendant waives a new trial. While Monday’s discussion included possible outcomes such as appeals to the state Supreme Court, Schulman said he was trying not to focus on such speculation.
“My job is to rule on the motions in front of me and not necessarily to figure out everybody’s subsequent moves on the chess board,” he said.
veryGood! (58)
Related
- Intel's stock did something it hasn't done since 2022
- Police find bodies of former TV reporter Jesse Baird and partner Luke Davies after alleged killer tells investigators where to look
- Ryan Gosling will sing 'I'm Just Ken' at the 2024 Oscars: Who else is performing?
- French Senate approves a bill to make abortion a constitutional right
- Civic engagement nonprofits say democracy needs support in between big elections. Do funders agree?
- An Ohio city is marking 30 years since the swearing-in of former US Treasurer Mary Ellen Withrow
- Lala Kent of 'Vanderpump Rules' is using IUI to get pregnant. What is that?
- Watch live: NASA, Intuitive Machines share updates on Odysseus moon lander
- What do we know about the mysterious drones reported flying over New Jersey?
- Mississippi ex-governor expected stake in firm that got welfare money, says woman convicted in fraud
Ranking
- Arkansas State Police probe death of woman found after officer
- Kia, Hyundai car owners can claim piece of $145M theft settlement next week, law firm says
- How genetically modified pigs could end the shortage of organs for transplants
- 7 California residents cash in multi-million dollar lottery tickets on the same day
- Most popular books of the week: See what topped USA TODAY's bestselling books list
- Ghana’s parliament passed an anti-LGBTQ+ bill that could imprison people for more than a decade
- Google CEO Sundar Pichai says its AI app problems are completely unacceptable
- Freight train carrying corn derails near Amtrak stop in northeast Nevada, no injuries reported
Recommendation
The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
At least 1 dead, multiple injured in Orlando shooting, police say
Watch live: NASA, Intuitive Machines share updates on Odysseus moon lander
Car theft suspect who fled police outside hospital is spotted, escapes from federal authorities
Grammy nominee Teddy Swims on love, growth and embracing change
Meet Syracuse's Dyaisha Fair, the best scorer in women's college basketball not named Caitlin Clark
From balmy to brrr: Wisconsin cities see a nearly 60-degree temperature swing in under 24 hours
A Missouri law forbids pregnant women from divorce. A proposed bill looks to change that.